अर्जुन उवाच ज्यायसी चेत्कर्मणस्ते मता बुद्धिर्जनार्दन। तत्किं कर्मणि घोरे मां नियोजयसि केशव
It is Arjuna who is speaking in this verse. He is addressing Krishna with titles like Janardana and Kesava, expressing his confusion about why Krishna, who praises knowledge as superior, is urging him toward dreadful action.
A workplace or household depends on many kinds of effort. Consider how your contribution affects others, instead of treating every task as a contest for personal recognition.
Go deeper into this verse
what specific action does Arjuna refer to as 'ghora karma' or dreadful action when questioning Krishna?
Arjuna refers to the act of fighting in the battle as the 'ghora karma' or dreadful action. He is anxious about participating in the war and is troubled by the idea of being involved in such violent deeds, especially when knowledge is said to be superior.
How does Arjuna address Krishna in his question about action and knowledge, and what do these names signify?
Arjuna addresses Krishna as Janardana and Kesava, which are respectful and affectionate names. Janardana means one who helps people, and Kesava refers to the slayer of the demon Kesi. These names reflect Arjuna's reverence and deep trust in Krishna's divine wisdom, even as he questions Him.
In Chapter 3, Verse 1, why does Arjuna feel confused when Krishna speaks of knowledge being superior to action but still asks him to fight?
Arjuna is confused because he sees a contradiction between Krishna's praise of knowledge and his instruction to fight in battle. He wonders why, if knowledge is held to be the highest path, he is being pushed toward a violent and difficult duty. This confusion arises from his desire to follow the best spiritual path and his fear of the consequences of his actions.
In Chapter 3, Verse 1, what underlying dilemma is Arjuna expressing when he asks Krishna about the superiority of knowledge over action?
Arjuna's dilemma is about understanding the true path to spiritual fulfillment. He wants to know whether he should pursue knowledge and renunciation, or perform his worldly duties. His question reflects a common human struggle: whether to act in the world or withdraw in pursuit of higher understanding. He seeks clarity from Krishna on how to reconcile wisdom with necessary action.
If it be thought by Thee that knowledge is superior to action, O Janârdana, why dost Thou, O Keshava, enjoin on me this terrible action?
What do “thy” and “thou” mean?
“Thy” means “your”; “thou” and “thee” mean “you”; “thine” means “yours.” This historical translation is preserved as published.